Fridgemaster Chest Freezer - White vs Undercounter Freezer - White — Comparison

The Fridgemaster MCF142E is a 142-litre chest freezer at £139, measuring 854mm high, 625mm wide and 559mm deep, with a listed weight of 27kg. It uses 183kWh a year, carries an E energy rating and makes 40dB of noise. The Fridgemaster MUZ4860E is an undercounter upright freezer at £130 with 61 litres of net capacity, 849mm high, 480mm wide and 448mm deep, weighing 20kg. It uses 156kWh a year, carries the same E rating, is slightly quieter at 38dB, and has three drawers, a reversible door and dial temperature control.

The choice comes down to space and how you will use it. The chest freezer offers more than twice the net capacity in a footprint that is still compact for its volume, and its open top suits bulky items. Buyers in garages and sheds like the internal light and say it runs very quietly. One owner kept it in a porch and found it needed shading during heatwaves, so keep it out of direct sun. The undercounter model fits under a worktop or into a cupboard, and its drawers let you reach items without digging. Buyers see it as a spillover freezer for a kitchen or office.

Reviewers raise a few drawbacks. The chest freezer's basket is considered small, and one buyer would like more baskets or a divider. One undercounter unit arrived with a missing foot and wobbled, so check the feet on delivery. Neither model is frost free, so plan on defrosting by hand from time to time.

Bottom line: choose the MCF142E if you need a large store for a garage or shed and want an interior light, choose the MUZ4860E if you need a slim freezer that fits under a worktop or into a small space.